The Howling
Wednesday 11th November 2010 @ The Komedia, Brighton The Komedia Upstairs is quite a peculiar venue by Brighton standards.
There’s nothing warm and friendly about it. Arriving early, as we did, really drove this point home. The Auditorium was empty except for about a dozen or so high tables with 3 or 4 bar stools arranged at each. Apart from this – emptiness.
The positive point was that we were able to grab a table and establish ourselves and wait for our friends – meaning us old folks didn’t need to stand all night and worry where we could put down our drinks while we bopped or hopped off to the little boys’ or girls’ room. Luckily it wasn’t long before more people started arriving, taking the chill out of the atmosphere. But imagine how my heart sank when I witnessed the arrival of a couple of clowns in the centre of the dancefloor.
If there’s one thing to upset my applecart, it’s the threat of people purveying Circus Skills! This turned out to be our MsC for the evening – a duo glorying under the epithet Foster and Gilvan [http://www.myspace.com/fostergilvan].
Mercifully, they merely did their thang for only a handful of minutes and, actually, turned out to be more than just mildly amusing – performiing a little bit of mime, a bit of audience intimidation and a song before introducing the evening’s first band, Bunty Le Jule [http://www.myspace.com/buntylejule]. Their MySpace Page fascinatingly bills them as being “2-step / Korean Pop / Zouk” but my description of their act might be experimental folk rock.
I presume they are quite a new/young band as although I found aspects of their presentation interesting – even intriguing – I feel they have not yet arrived at the level of performance that would make me want to rush out and see them.
They have written some nice songs and the instrumentation is imaginative and adventurous. But I feel they’re probably trying to cover far too much ground and appear incredibly versatile at a stage in their development when they should be perhaps honing and polishing some aspects of their act and letting some others sit on the back burner till later.
All through the performance, whilst being, constantly impressed by the arrival of yet another new instrument or style, I felt there was something lacking. On reflection I think it’s more than one thing, but it’s mainly some sort of cohesion.
The best bands exhibit some sort of Gestalt - the band is bigger than the individual contributions. In this case our attention was repeatedly drawn to one band member or instrument rather than seeing the whole picture of a band gelling together and making a marvellous sound.
If the foregoing sounds hard and over-judgmental, I apologise but would excuse myself by saying this band exhibits such promise and potential, that I’d like to see them go places with some of the original ideas they clearly have on offer. I hope they do not think that they’re yet firing on all cylinders. I’d like them to take a step back and take a good look at themselves and identify their greatest strengths. They might then be able to develop these into a highly polished act, which will stand out from the crowd and allow them to move beyond a niche market in which I fear they would otherwise be ghettoised and languish.

After a further dose of Foster & Gilvan, we came onto The Moulettes [www.myspace.com/moulettes ] who most definitely did have that missing gestalt. In fact, they have to be just about one of the most complete bands around at the moment. Not only do they have both cello and bassoon as part of the regular line-up, they are positively overflowing with different vocal talents and know how to put on a jolly good show.
The Moulettes cover a huge range of genres – folk, jazz, rock and classical – but are primarily entertainers and as such have developed their act according to their strengths and have built from there until they know just how far they can go before falling flat on their face. This takes talent, practice and time.
More MC madness…
...before… The Muel [www.myspace.com/samwalkers ]. I’ve written many times, it seems, on various projects Sam Walker has been engaged in and rarely have much to complain about. Whatever he does seems to be well thought out, pushes boundaries and he never fails to entertain.
Turning Green [http://www.myspace.com/turninggreen ] has most probably been his most successful venture – and remains one of my very favourite all times bands. But this was a joint undertaking with a co-operaative group of equals each bringing individual skills to produce an ensemble whole. He’s never really tasted the big time success with one of his more personal ventures that he deserves – popular wherever he goes, yes – but not quite a household name.
However, this line-up – Sam [The Muel] with a big band of excellent musicians providing the backing for his own distinctive brand of powerful pop and rock, is the format with which I feel he’s most likely to grab some attention from a wider musical hinterland.
The songs were much the same as he’s been performing in more intimate venues either solo or with 1 or 2 collaborators – such as with The Adventurists. But this line-up which included guitars, strings and brass with Sam in his natural element – drums and percussion – works so well. I’d love to see him make this his main project for the near future. He seems perfectly at home directing the band in the style of Frank Zappa or Nigel Kennedy!

This really was a perfect night out. At every turn there was a new delight on which to feast one’s eyes and ears.
All Killer – No Filler.
Recent Comments