I have been trying to reply to a Gavin Wilson who wrote a review of Van der Graaf Generator's first proper album "The Least..." on the Amazon website back in 2001.
Amazon won't let me post as I've never bouight from them using this name! How petty can they get?
Anyway this is what he said...
4.0 out of 5 stars The first proper VdGG album, but who were Mike and Susie?,
August 22, 2001 By Gavin Wilson
- See all my reviews (TOP 500 REVIEWER) (REAL NAME)
While most rock songs concerned themselves with the business of getting off with girls, Peter Hammill had other things on his mind: you don't get lines like "Malleus Maleficarum slaughtered and tortured" in your average rock lyric.
This album portrays Hammill's vision of some sort of occult-related nuclear apocalypse.
This band was so underground they were molten -- without being magma, of course ;-)
I feel that liking this album is going to be a tough assignment for newcomers.
I've known Van Der Graaf for 28 years, and this album for a week. I love the albums I knew in my youth -- particularly GODBLUFF, STILL LIFE and PAWN HEARTS -- but, at the age of 42, I struggle to digest new VdGG discoveries.
As always with VdGG albums, this one improves with each hearing. After about my fourth hearing, I was so disillusioned that I was all prepared to write a short of essay entitled, 'Whatever was the point in progressive music?', focussing on the assertion that teenagers and students in the early 70s had less money but less choice of leisure products -- no video, no Nintendo, and in the UK at least, no all-day TV.
But after several more auditions, I believe this album stacks up well (without being quite so excellent) as the other three I named.
All the VdGG ingredients are here, fully-formed -- even the fledgling special effects. (I would imagine Hammill is quite embarrassed today about the dalek voice borrowed from the BBC Radiophonic Workshop used to sing the 'total annihilation' lyric in 'After the Flood'.) As other reviewers have said, this album owes something to IN THE COURT OF THE CRIMSON KING; there are also very faint echoes of the acoustic guitar style of Bowie's SPACE ODDITY and Jethro Tull's flute.
Despite the fact that 'Refugees' from this album was VdGG's biggest UK single (no less than #47 in the hit parade!), I wouldn't recommend this as the first port of call for a VdGG newcomer -- possibly STILL LIFE and the remastered collection in INTRODUCTION are the best starting points.
Provided you give them enough time, you'll soon find that buying VdGG albums becomes addictive. And you'll end up buying this one, even if it takes 28 years.
And maybe you'll be able to help me understand the line 'West is Mike and Susie'.
In the hope that Gavin comes across this or someone who reads this can direct him this way, here is my response...
A good review but having been a fan of this album since 1970, I think you have a long way to go in its appreciation.
Your comments on VdGG lyrics being so different are spot on and while I understand your placing of 'Still Life' and 'Pawn Hearts' as being so important in terms of music and the pinnacle of the prog rock cannon, 'The Least...' takes its place in my all time favourites LP list alongside Neil Young's 'Everybody Kows this is Nowhere', David Crosby's 'If Only I could Remember My Name' as my Top 3.
The Mike and Susie Question remains a mystery to me but I like it that way - this is not science - it's a spiritual song - about the soul - and the mystery of life and death is central to that.
I always releated 'Refugees' to the scenes at the end of Lord of the Rings when the Elves take their voyage from the Grey Havens 'into the West' carrying Bilbo along with them - this is a portayal of death to me that says it all - I am not religious but very much hope there is something which we experience in death which sums it all up. Even if there is nothing beyond that.
Although I doubt this will be so, I live in hope!
Keep listening, Gavin, to this wonderful album - I've never tired of it - always finding more in it than I've noticed before - I DO love the 'Annihilation' bit in 'After The Flood' - but I love really Heavy Metal sounds too.
Prog Rock has never been the same since the demise of VdGG - they were Kings of the Artform at their best.
Sadly recent releases have been somewhat disappointing - that must be largely due to the absence of JaxonSax - a manwho has no parallel in rock music and is sadly missed
best wishes
Abi Rhodes
www.abi-rhodes.typepad.com
Recent Comments